Jane Magnolia and the Little Girl Hybrids Compared

Jane Magnolia and the Little Girl Hybrids Compared

Which Little Girl magnolia should I plant? It's the question customers ask us most, and our answer is Jane, unless your space is tight or you want a dark flower. She blooms late, grows slowly, and her timing often dodges the frost that ruins earlier magnolias.

Jane Magnolia nursery tree
Jane Magnolia Nursery-grown Jane Magnolia, shipped to your door. Sizes from 1 Gallon 1-2 Feet Multi Stem. From $80.55.
Shop Now →

The wrong pick costs you. A magnolia that outgrows its spot gets hacked back, and one that opens too early gets browned petals. The right one gives you scented purple-pink flowers year after year.

Read on for how Jane compares with Ann, Betty, Susan, Ricki and Pinkie. Then we follow the year, from winter planning and spring planting to the April bloom, summer water and fall leaf checks.

Winter: Meet Jane Magnolia and the Little Girl Series

Winter is when you choose, so start by knowing what the series is and what sets Jane apart from her sisters. She is a hybrid from the 1950s, so she has no wild native range.

The Little Girl series is a group of hybrid magnolias bred at the U.S. National Arboretum, each named for a girl's first name. They cross Magnolia liliiflora (lily magnolia, from China) with Magnolia stellata (star magnolia, from Japan). Jane herself comes from M. liliflora 'Reflorescens' and M. stellata 'Waterlily'. The result is deciduous shrubs or small trees that top out between 6 and 15 feet, far more manageable than a saucer magnolia.

The main Little Girl cultivars include Jane, Ann, Betty, Judy, Randy, Ricki, Susan, and Pinkie. Each has its own bloom window, flower color, and form, but all share the series' defining traits: hardiness to USDA zones 4-8, moderate growth rates, and attractive late-spring or mid-spring flowering. For home gardeners accustomed to plants that run 30 feet or more, these hybrids feel almost like a different species in terms of practicality.

Winter: Compare Jane With Her Sisters Before You Buy

Use the quiet months to pick a cultivar while you can still plan the bed and order. The table below sets the eight main Little Girls side by side.

Cultivar Mature Height Bloom Time Flower Color Bloom Duration Winter Hardiness
Jane 10-15 ft Mid-to-late spring Purple-pink outside, pale pink/lavender inside Moderate, with sporadic summer rebloom Zones 4-8
Ann 8-10 ft Late spring (similar to Jane) Dark purplish-red outside, white inside Moderate, with occasional summer flowers Zones 4-8
Betty 10-15 ft Late spring Deep purple-red flowers Extended bloom period Zones 4-8
Judy 10-12 ft Late spring Purple-red outer petals Extended season Zones 4-8
Susan 8-10 ft Late spring (latest of the group) Deep purple-red Extended, but not reliably reblooming Zones 4-8
Ricki 6-8 ft Late spring Purple flowers Moderate Zones 4-8
Randy 8-10 ft Late spring Purple-pink Moderate Zones 4-8
Pinkie 10-12 ft Late spring Pink flowers Moderate Zones 4-8

Jane vs. Ann: The Closest Comparison

Ann is the Little Girl closest to Jane in looks and habit. Both bloom in late spring, but Ann stays smaller at 8–10 feet while Jane reaches 10–15 feet. A few differences decide most choices.

Ann's flowers are darker purplish-red outside with white interiors, while Jane leans reddish-purple with pale pink or lavender tones inside. Both want consistent moisture, well-drained soil, acidic to neutral pH and protection from late frost during bloom. Our Jane vs. Ann comparison goes deeper on size and flower color.

What we tell customers is to let space decide first and color second. If you have 8–10 feet to fill and like deeper red tones, plant Ann. If you have 12–15 feet and like softer purple-pink shades, plant Jane.

Jane vs. Betty, Susan and the Darker Bloomers

Betty and Susan sit at the deeper-colored end of the palette. Both have rich dark purple-red flowers, though neither reblooms reliably. Betty matures at about 10–15 feet tall and 8–12 feet wide. Susan is similar in size and often cited as the latest bloomer in the series.

Jane's lighter, more rose-toned flowers offer a softer landscape presence than Betty or Susan. If your garden leans toward cool purples and deep jewel tones elsewhere, Betty or Susan might harmonize better. Conversely, if you're pairing the magnolia with pastels, spring bulbs, or lighter perennials, Jane's intermediate tone strikes a different balance.

Reblooming frequency varies by climate and growing conditions. None of these cultivars should be planted with an expectation of predictable summer flowers, but in favorable sites (consistent moisture, full sun, established health), the deeper varieties seem to offer more reliable second flushes.

Jane vs. the Compact Cultivars, Ricki and Pinkie

Ricki is the smallest of the Little Girl group, maxing out around 6-8 feet, making her ideal for tight spaces, narrow side yards, or container cultivation when young. Her purple flowers and compact habit make her a specialist choice for gardeners who need a true dwarf shrub.

Pinkie rounds out the group with pink flowers and a mature height of 10-12 feet. She offers a color option different from the red and purple dominants elsewhere in the series. Pinkie pairs well with shade gardens where her lighter blooms brighten shadier sections.

Jane sits between these extremes in size and offers a broader middle-ground choice if you want substantial presence without Pinkie's pink tones and without going as small as Ricki.

Early Spring: Site, Plant and Feed Jane Magnolia

Early spring is when we plant most Janes and when we feed established ones. Get the site right first, then follow the steps below.

Pick the Spot and Soil

Jane does best in full sun and accepts partial shade, though she flowers most heavily with at least six hours of direct light. She likes consistently moist, well-drained, humus-rich soil that runs slightly acidic to neutral.

She tolerates heavy clay, air pollution and heat, but once established she still needs water in dry spells. If your soil runs high in pH, expect yellowing leaves, which we cover under the fall checks.

Plant in Five Steps

Follow these steps and she will settle in without fuss. For more detail, see our guide to planting a Jane Magnolia.

  1. Choose a spot with full sun and shelter from strong wind, which can damage flower buds.
  2. Leave room for 10–15 feet of height and 8–12 feet of spread. She is slow-growing, so she looks small for years. We often see customers crowd her against a house for that reason.
  3. Dig the hole twice as wide as the root ball and no deeper than it.
  4. Backfill with the soil you dug out. Common advice says to mix in sand to fix clay, but we don't, because Jane copes with clay and sand can make the soil set harder.
  5. Water slowly and deeply, then mulch a few inches deep, keeping it off the trunk.

Feed in Spring, Prune Only After Bloom

Feeding is light and pruning is rare. You may hear that magnolias should be tidied in late winter. We don't do that, because next year's flower buds are already set on old wood and you would cut off the bloom.

Minimal pruning is necessary for any Little Girl magnolia. If shaping is needed, prune right after flowering since flower buds for the next year set on old wood soon after bloom. Light annual feeding in early spring with a balanced, slow-release, acid-forming fertilizer formulated for trees and shrubs supports steady growth. For more detailed care guidance across all seasons, check our complete Jane Magnolia care guide for every season.

Mid-April to Early May: Enjoy Jane Magnolia in Bloom

The bloom is why you planted her, so give it a little attention for the few weeks it lasts.

Jane opens from mid-April to early May. The Little Girls bloom two to four weeks later than their parent species, and that delay is why her flowers often miss the frost that browns earlier bloomers. The blossoms are reddish-purple to purple-pink outside, with white to pale pink or lavender insides, and they carry a mild, sweet fragrance.

Plant her where you pass every day, beside a door or along a path, so you catch the scent on warm afternoons. In our rows, the first bees reach the open flowers on those afternoons.

When a hard freeze is forecast with flowers open, drape an old sheet or burlap over the tree at dusk and pull it off the next morning. Use cloth, not plastic.

If you garden in zones 4–5, Jane's late bloom is a real advantage, since late spring frosts tend to be milder than early spring ones.

If you have pets, the ASPCA lists star magnolia, one of Jane's parents, as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses. That page covers the species, not Jane herself, so keep an eye on a curious chewer.

Summer and Fall: Water, Watch and Mulch

After the petals drop, the work shifts to moisture in summer and leaf checks in fall.

Summer: Water Deeply

Jane is not drought tolerant, so summer comes down to moisture. Soak the root zone slowly whenever a week passes without rain, and keep the mulch topped up. Our watering guide covers young and mature trees.

All Little Girl cultivars share the same core needs. They are hardy in USDA zones 4–8, want medium, consistent moisture, and do best in well-drained, humus-rich soil that is slightly acidic to neutral.

Salt tolerance is low across the group, which makes them poor choices for roadsides or places with winter salt spray. Deer resistance is moderate. None are preferred browse, but hungry deer in a hard winter may nibble buds or young growth.

Fall: Check Leaves and Mulch Before Winter

In early fall, walk the tree and look at leaves top and bottom. Catching a problem now protects next spring's bloom, and most of what we find is minor.

Regional pest and disease pressure varies. Scale insects, magnolia weevil (occasional and regional), leaf spot fungi, and canker may appear, but none are guaranteed on any single plant. Chlorosis can develop in soils that trend toward high pH or alkaline conditions. The most consistent challenge across all Little Girls is late frost damage to open flowers in some years, despite the series' later bloom timing relative to star magnolia.

Top up the mulch and water deeply if fall has been dry, so the roots go into winter moist.

Through the Year: Where Jane Wins and Where Another Little Girl Does

Once you have seen Jane through every season, the trade-offs are clear. Here is what she does well, what she doesn't, and where each sister fits better.

Jane's Strengths and Limits

These are the points that decide it for most customers.

Jane's Strengths: Her mid-April to early May bloom reduces late frost risk. A mature height of 10–15 feet offers visual presence without overwhelming a small yard. Rose-toned flowers bridge the gap between pale and deep purples, suiting a wider range of companion plantings. Slow growth makes her predictable as she matures.

Jane's Challenges: She is not drought tolerant, so consistent moisture is mandatory. Low salt tolerance rules out coastal or high-salt-spray sites. Rebloom is sporadic and less reliable than on some sister cultivars. High-pH or alkaline soils cause chlorosis. Strong wind can damage flower buds.

When to Choose Ann Instead: Tighter space budgets favor Ann's 8-10 foot mature height. Darker flower tones might suit your design goals. None of the Little Girl magnolias rebloom reliably, though Ann may give occasional summer flowers.

When to Choose Susan or Betty Instead: Darker flowers justify the choice if that trait aligns with your hardscape and companion plantings. None of the Little Girl magnolias rebloom reliably, though Ann may give occasional summer flowers.

When to Choose Ricki: True compact needs (narrow side yards, containers for young plants, tight foundation beds) push toward Ricki's 6-8 foot final height.

When to Choose Pinkie: Pink-toned gardens or shade-heavy landscapes benefit from Pinkie's lighter hue and soft appearance.

Best Uses by Site

If you know where the tree is going, this is the quickest way to match a cultivar to the spot.

Small urban gardens (under 1,500 sq ft total): Ann or Ricki. Jane works if you have a 15-foot sight line without hemming her in on all sides.

Mixed shrub borders and multi-season interest: Jane or Susan. Pairing with azaleas, rhododendrons, or hostas gives you layered spring color plus reliable summer foliage contrast.

Specimen tree placement (focal point in lawn): Jane at her full 10-15 feet. Her form and winter buds shine on their own.

Shade gardens: Pinkie if you want a lighter tone. Jane if you prefer the middle-ground rose tones and have dappled light.

Coastal or high-wind sites: None of the Little Girls are ideal, but if magnolias are a must, choose a protected microclimate and monitor flower bud damage.

Gardens where reblooming is a priority: None of the Little Girl magnolias rebloom reliably. Ann may give occasional summer flowers. Expect rebloom in favorable years, not as a guarantee.

Quick Reference: Little Girl Magnolia Selector

Use this table to match your top priority to a cultivar.

Your Priority Best Choice Why
Smallest mature size Ricki (6-8 ft) Only true dwarf in the series
Compact without going mini Ann (8-10 ft) Slightly smaller than Jane, darker flowers
Balanced height and appearance Jane (10-15 ft) Mid-range size, mid-tone rose-purple, late bloom timing
Darkest flowers and reblooming Susan or Betty Extended bloom and summer reflush
Pink instead of purple Pinkie (10-12 ft) Only pink-flowered Little Girl option
Shade tolerance Any (all tolerate part shade) Full sun yields best flowering, and Pinkie is less demanding
Frost-resistant bloom timing Jane or Susan Bloom latest in spring, dodging earlier freeze events
Zone 4 reliability Any Little Girl (all zones 4-8) All equally winter hardy, and Jane's later bloom is a practical plus

Why Jane Magnolia Stays Our Default Little Girl

The "best" Little Girl magnolia depends on your site constraints and aesthetic goals. Ann edges Jane for tight spaces. Susan and Betty earn preference if your garden design hinges on darker purples and reblooming. Ricki is the only choice for true compact niches. Pinkie fills the pink-toned niche.

Jane Magnolia nursery tree

Jane Magnolia

Nursery-grown Jane Magnolia in sizes from 1 Gallon 1-2 Feet Multi Stem, shipped to your door.

From $80.55

Shop Now →

For one magnolia with no limiting factor, Jane is the one we reach for: late, scented and steady. Our growers watch her buds in April, her soil moisture in July and her leaves in October on our own farms, where we grow and sell top-quality magnolias, shrubs and trees.